Two prayer timetables can show different clock times for the same place and day. Before deciding that one must contain an error, it helps to compare what each timetable is calculating.

A schedule depends on a location, a date, a timezone and calculation conventions. It may also include adjustments made by its publisher. This guide explains those technical differences. It does not choose a religious convention for you or decide whether a prayer is valid.

Start with the same place and day

First check that both schedules refer to the same date and location. A city label may represent a central coordinate rather than the exact point used by another service. Longitude and latitude affect the Sun's apparent position, so two location inputs need not produce identical results. The PrayTimes calculation explanation identifies coordinates, timezone and date-dependent solar quantities as calculation inputs.

A timezone translates an astronomical event into a local clock reading. A wrong offset can make the whole schedule look shifted even when the underlying calculation is similar. In places that observe daylight saving time, the applicable offset can also change during the year. NIST's daylight saving explanation describes the clock changes used in the United States; other locations have their own rules.

As a practical comparison, check the displayed timezone and whether each schedule handles the selected date's daylight saving rule. Do this before interpreting a large clock-time difference as a disagreement about prayer methods.

Fajr and Isha use method conventions

Many methods calculate Fajr and Isha using a specified solar angle below the horizon. Different angle settings identify different moments during the morning or evening. Some Isha conventions instead use a set interval after Maghrib.

For example, PrayTimes documents Muslim World League settings of 18 degrees for Fajr and 17 degrees for Isha, alongside other conventions with different values. These are descriptions of calculation settings, not a recommendation to adopt one. Changing a setting changes the computational question being asked.

The AlAdhan method documentation also distinguishes angles from minute-based intervals. A method name is therefore useful information, but the actual parameters matter when comparing implementations. Check whether the two timetables use the same Fajr angle, Isha rule and any applicable adjustments.

Asr can use a different shadow factor

Asr calculations commonly use a shadow-length convention. Two familiar settings use an object's height multiplied by one or by two, in addition to its shadow at solar noon. A change in that factor changes the calculated Asr time even if the other inputs agree.

The PrayTimes documentation describes these alternatives. This guide is identifying an input that can explain a difference; it is not adjudicating between schools of practice. A method label for Fajr and Isha also does not necessarily tell you the Asr setting, so compare it separately.

Small differences can have other causes

Rounding and explicit minute adjustments can move a displayed time without changing the main method. The PrayTimes manual documents both tuning and rounding options. It also describes higher-latitude rules for conditions where the ordinary twilight calculation cannot supply the requested event. Those rules are another setting to compare, particularly in summer.

Even astronomical rise and set predictions use assumptions. The U.S. Naval Observatory explains that standard definitions assume average atmospheric conditions and a level horizon. Local observing conditions are more complicated than a clock display can show. This is a reason to read a timetable's notes, rather than interpret minute-level precision as a guarantee about observation.

A mosque timetable may answer a different question

Check the labels on a local mosque schedule. Does a column describe the beginning of a prayer time, or the congregation's scheduled iqamah? Those are different pieces of information. If a timetable does not explain its labels or adjustments, ask its publisher what the columns mean.

AlAdhan documents that publishers can tune calculated times. Matching a named method alone therefore does not establish that a software result reproduces a particular mosque's schedule. Without the publisher's own explanation, we should not guess which adjustment it uses or attach its authority to a generic calculator.

Compare responsibly

Before comparing two schedules, work through this checklist:

  • Date and place: use the same Gregorian date and latitude/longitude, rather than relying only on a city name.
  • Timezone: compare the IANA timezone, such as America/New_York, and its daylight-saving offset for that date.
  • Fajr and Isha: compare the calculation method's actual angles or interval rules, not just its name.
  • Asr: check the separate Standard or Hanafi shadow-factor setting.
  • Minute adjustments: record each explicit per-prayer offset, including its sign; zero is different from an undisclosed adjustment.
  • High latitudes: where twilight is prolonged, compare the selected rule. Salati offers middle-of-night, seventh-of-night and twilight-angle handling; polar dates without usable sunrise or sunset may remain unavailable.
  • Comparable columns: distinguish calculated prayer times from a mosque's scheduled iqamah; ask the timetable publisher what its labels mean.

A screenshot of two numbers rarely contains enough context to diagnose the difference. None of these settings establishes a universally authoritative method or an official local timetable.

For a question about local observance or which convention to follow, consult a trusted local mosque or qualified person familiar with your circumstances. A technical guide can explain inputs; it cannot replace that guidance.

Use the free Prayer Times calculator to explore daily and monthly calculated schedules with your location, timezone, method, Asr setting and optional minute adjustments. A user-adjusted calculation is not a mosque-issued timetable. This article does not provide a verified local timetable or an official observance announcement.